What’s Inn a Name?

The Odd Whim
Ashton-under-Lyne
Reference: Lancashire Life February 1981 by Cliff Astin

The sudden fancy to which this pub’s name refers is the religious fantatic Johana Southcott’s notion that she was about to give birth to Shiloh, the Massiah of Peace named by Patriarch Jacob. October 19, 1814, was the appointed day for delivery, and the lady’s appearance certainly lent weight to her many Ashton supporters expectations (the Odd Whim was formerly a Christian Israelite meeting-place).
When Shiloh failed to appear, it was announced that Joanna was in a trance, and she died a few days later … not for an unusual pregnancy, but from brain disease. Her expectant appearance, a post-mortem examination revealed, had been caused by dropsy.
It was at The Odd Whim that a special jury sat in deliberation on another religious matter – the scandalous behaviour of the town’s leader of the Christian Israelites, John Wroe, who claimed to have received a directive from Heaven to take to himself seven virgins to cherish and comfort him. Three of his Ashton followers donated their daughters, and with them Wroe travelled the country on various missions … until public outcry caused him to flee to Australia.
None of which explains the oddest whim of all – the brewery’s choice of the witch for the pub’s signboard.
Cliff Astin 1981

Reference the trial of John Wroe allegedly held at the Odd Whim, the following information was supplied by of The Christian Israelite Church in Australia:-

According to John Wroe's journals on Sunday 24th October, 1830 at 2pm, the people assembled at the house of a friend, east of Ashton, for the purpose of trying John Wroe. That is the closest description I can get of where that trial took place. At the end of the trial, with 12 members of the jury, the jury announced after hearing all the evidence, concluded that they could not condemn him, and therefore agreed to acquit him; and the chairman said, "I say as Pilate said to teh Jews of old, when our Lord was before him: I wash my hands from the blood of this man." The politics and machinations of this period of Israelite history would make an interesting study. As far as JW travelling the country goes, a journal was kept from 1822 - 1863 and in the early days all entries were written by a gentleman who accompanied him on all his travels. This is again a matter of folklore. His wife Mary Wroe was pregnant at the time and did have later children - she didn't pass away till the 1850's.
Lynne Gray CIC

The words Odd Whim have/are used to refer to a phantom pregnancy' (technical term is pseudocyesis) and locally an Odd Whim was referred to as a 'Witch' so how did the brewery come up with the name and the Pub's sign?. Perhaps it will always remain a mystery; one thing that will remain are the memories of the Odd Whim Public House it's Landlord's, customers characters and all, not to forget 'Red Ned' the ghost of the Odd Whim. Seen by some felt by others but harmless, 'who was Red Ned'? yet another name associated with the Odd Whim were no one can give a full explanation.